← Blog

Craft

How do you check if your website is good?

09 October 2026 · 6 min

Editorial illustration of a clipboard checklist beside a browser window, one line ticked in orange, navy on a cream background

Not how it looks — whether it works. Six checks that take an afternoon and tell you more than any opinion ever will.

Ask ten people whether a website is good and you'll get ten opinions about fonts. A better question: does it do its job? A good website gets the right people to find it, believe it and act. That's checkable — here are six checks worth an afternoon of anyone's time.

1. The five-second test

Show the first screen of your homepage to someone outside your industry. Can they tell you what you do, who it's for and what to do next? If they hesitate, so do your visitors — and hesitant visitors leave. This is the cheapest fix on the list because it's copy and structure, not technology.

2. Can people find it

Search for the phrase a customer would actually type — not your brand name. If competitors fill the results and you're nowhere, the site has a findability problem: technical health, thin content, or pages built around what you call things rather than what customers search. Fixing this starts with the boring foundations; our free website score reports on them in plain English.

3. Does it work on a phone

Most of your traffic is mobile, so test like it. Load the site on your phone on a weak connection. Pinch-zooming to read? A menu that fights you? A form that takes five minutes? Any one of those is enough for a visitor to go back to the search results and pick a competitor.

4. Is there proof

Every business says it's professional, experienced and customer-focused. None of it registers without evidence. Look at your own site as a sceptic: is there a case study with a real outcome, photography of your actual work, a named human? Prove it rather than claim it.

5. Is the next step obvious

Every page should offer a route to the next step, and the route should be tested. Submit your own enquiry form today. If the notification goes nowhere, the site has been quietly eating leads — it looks identical to 'no leads' from the outside and is far more common than people think.

The gap between a convinced visitor and a sent enquiry is where most websites lose the money they were built to make.

6. What the numbers say

Site-wide traffic tells you very little. Look at conversion rate per landing page instead — it shows which pages convince and which just collect visitors. We walked through that diagnosis in traffic but no leads.

Scoring yourself honestly

Six checks, one afternoon, and you'll know more about your site than most agencies would tell you in a pitch meeting. If most of them pass, invest in content and proof. If several fail, read the signs a redesign is justified before spending anything — and if you want a second opinion on the technical side, send us the link. You'll get an honest read, including when the answer is 'it's fine'.

Talk it through

Not sure what your website needs?

Tell us what you’re trying to fix. We’ll reply within two working days with an honest view, even if the answer is that you don’t need us.